Alaska voters reject repeal of ranked choice voting and top-four primaries for a second time
A ballot measure that would have repealed Alaska's nonpartisan primary system and ranked choice voting has failed, according to projections by the Associated Press and NBC News. It is the second time Alaskans have voted down a repeal. Voters first approved the system in 2020, and a repeal attempt in 2024 failed by fewer than 800 votes.
Under the system, candidates of all parties run on one primary ballot and the top four advance to the general election. Voters then rank the candidates in order of preference. If nobody wins more than 50% of first choices, the last-placed candidate is eliminated and their votes are passed to voters' next choices, and this repeats until someone has a majority. Alaska and Maine are the only states that use ranked choice voting for statewide elections.
The system came under intense scrutiny this year because the four-person US Senate ballot included two candidates called Dan Sullivan: the Republican incumbent and an independent, a retired teacher named Dan J. Sullivan. Opponents of the system said the independent was a spoiler recruited by Democrats to split votes. The New York Times reported a week before election day that Democratic candidate Mary Peltola's campaign was involved in recruiting him. Peltola and her campaign deny pushing him to run or being involved in his campaign, and the independent has defended his candidacy. The matter is under federal and state investigation. A federal judge earlier this month dismissed a Trump administration effort to segregate ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan. The Senate race appears likely to go to a ranked choice count.
Supporters say ranked choice voting blunts the effect of confusion because voters could rank both Sullivans. They say it gives voters more power and rewards candidates who appeal beyond the extremes of their party. Critics call the system confusing and open to manipulation.