First national rules for a contested organ retrieval method draw ethics criticism
The US organ transplant system has approved its first national policy for normothermic regional perfusion (NRP), a controversial procedure for retrieving organs from hospital patients. The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network board approved the guidelines on Nov. 6, and they take effect on Dec. 6. The network works under the supervision of the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA).
NRP is used after a family has decided to withdraw care because there is no hope of meaningful recovery. Minutes after circulation has stopped and the patient has been declared dead, doctors connect an external pump that restores blood flow to the heart, lungs, kidneys, liver and other organs so they do not deteriorate. To make sure the donor is also brain dead, surgeons clamp the blood vessels that supply the head. The new guidelines require blood vessels to the brain to be clamped, and recommend against giving drugs that paralyse donors, since those could mask movement.
Dr. Raymond Lynch, HRSA's director of transplantation, said NRP could help ease the chronic shortage and improve organ quality. More than 109,000 Americans are waiting for a transplant, and about 12 die each day.
Critics say NRP is unethical because it violates the dead donor rule, the central protection for donors, which says surgeons may take organs only from patients who are dead from brain death or circulatory death. Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross, a bioethicist at the University of Rochester, said death by circulatory criteria means no attempt will be made to restore circulation, yet that is exactly what NRP does, so organs are taken from people who are no longer dead. Critics also say the guidelines do little to improve safety, noting concern in retrieval teams when blood appeared to reach the brain during procedures.